You've seen the headlines. Mortgage rates are back over 7 percent. National home prices slipped in October for the first time in three years. Almost every week, someone in Fargo, West Fargo, or Moorhead asks me the same question: is now a bad time to buy?
I'm Tyler Bretz, managing broker at Raboin Realty in West Fargo. I've been working this market for seven years. The honest answer is that the national story is not our story. This is not 2021, and it is not a crash. It's a more normal market. Whether it's a good time depends on who you are, what you can comfortably pay, and how you buy.
What the headlines are missing
As of November 12, the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate was 7.11 percent, according to Freddie Mac. That's up from 6.24 percent a year ago, so the payment really is heavier than last fall. It is also well below the 7.79 percent peak on October 26, 2023, and it has eased from 7.40 percent in mid-October. Rates are high. They are not at the top of this cycle, and they have been moving in the right direction.
Nationally, Redfin reported that the median U.S. sale price in October was $388,634, down 0.35 percent from a year earlier, the first year-over-year decline since May 2023. Inventory is up 2 percent across the country. That's the "bad market" story. It is not what the numbers show on our side of the Red River.
What's actually happening in Fargo, West Fargo, and Moorhead
Look at the three months ending in October, a cleaner read than any single month. Redfin puts Fargo's median sale price at $331,769, up 2.1 percent from a year ago. West Fargo's median is $365,746, up 1.3 percent. Moorhead is the exception: $265,815, down 5.1 percent.
The county numbers tell a similar story over a longer stretch. In Cass County, which includes Fargo, West Fargo, and Horace, the year-to-date median is $348,900, up 2.9 percent. In Clay County, which includes Moorhead and Dilworth, the year-to-date median is $289,250, up 4.8 percent, even though October itself was softer. One month's median jumps around depending on which homes closed. The longer view is modest growth, not a slide.
October was slow. Across Cass and Clay counties, 267 homes closed, down 24.4 percent from last October. Pending sales fell 20 percent, to 360. New listings came in at 355, down 13.4 percent. Year to date, though, metro sales are still up 1.3 percent. One quiet month at the start of the off-season is not a trend.
There were 1,282 active listings in October, down 5.9 percent from a year ago. Months of supply sits at 4.09 on the Fargo side and 4.56 on the Moorhead side, which is a balanced market. In Fargo, the typical home sold in 29 days over the last three months, down from 39 a year ago. In West Fargo it was 27 days, down from 36. In Moorhead it was 36 days, a couple of days slower than last year.
Buyers also have more room to negotiate than they did during the frenzy years. Fargo homes sold for about 98.8 percent of list price. Moorhead was 98.9 percent. West Fargo is tighter, at 99.6 percent, and a larger share of those sales still go over asking.
Who it's a good time for, and who should wait
It's a better time than the headlines suggest for move-up buyers. You can often negotiate on the home you're buying, and a well-priced home in Fargo or West Fargo is still selling in about a month. The real question is whether the payment on the next house works, and whether your current house will sell if you price it to today's competition.
It's also a more interesting time for investors willing to underwrite a deal, especially in Moorhead, where recent prices are softer and listings are up from a year ago. Softer is not the same as cheap. Run the rent, the taxes, the specials, and the vacancy before you call it an opportunity.
If a home is selling at or a little under list, it is reasonable to ask for repairs, closing-cost help, or a rate buydown, especially if it has been sitting. That is less true on a sharp, well-priced listing in West Fargo.
Who should wait? Anyone whose purchase only works if rates fall and local prices drop. Fargo and West Fargo prices are not dropping. Anyone stretching to the maximum payment on a house they don't love. And sellers who need to move first but are still priced for last spring. On the Moorhead side especially, a high price just means more days on the market.
How to buy smarter in a 7 percent market
Ask for a seller-paid buydown. A temporary 2-1 buydown can take pressure off the first two years. A permanent buydown costs more at the table, but the seller can pay it as a concession, and you keep the lower rate for the life of the loan.
Ask for closing-cost help. In a balanced market, that is a normal part of the negotiation, not an insult.
Use the leverage you actually have. Most homes here are not selling over list. Offer from the comps and the condition, not from a fear of losing the house.
Plan as if today's rate is the rate. If rates come down later, you can refinance. If the payment only works after a refinance, it doesn't work yet.
Buy a home you want to own in Fargo-Moorhead on a payment you can live with. That has been the right approach in every market I've worked.
If you're trying to decide whether to buy, sell, or wait, I'll run the numbers with you. We can look at the payment, the neighborhood, and, if you already own, what your current home is likely to do in this market. Call or text me at (701) 541-7192, or reach out to Raboin Realty. No national talking points. Just the local math.